• map
  • Map
  • Homes
  • Condos
  • New Construction
  • Waterfront
  • Neighborhoods
  • Condo Buildings
  • Cities
  • Popular
  • Articles
  • Builders
  • Contact
  • Selling
  • Buying
    • to
    Reset
    Houses
    Townhouses
    Condos
    Land
    Price
    to
    SQFT
    to
    Bdrms
    to
    Baths
    to
    Lot
    to
    Yr Built
    to
    Sold
    Listed within...
    Listed at least...
    Offer Review
    New Construction
    Waterfront
    Short-Sales
    REO
    Parking
    to
    Unit Flr
    to
    Unit Nbr
    Types
    Listings
    Neighborhoods
    Complexes
    Developments
    Cities
    Counties
    Zip Codes
    Neighborhood · Condo · Development
    School District
    Zip Code
    City
    County
    Builder
    Listing Numbers
    Broker LAG
    Display Settings
    Boundary Lines
    Labels
    View
    Sort
    Contact Us
    24  Photos layers Layout ondemand_videoVideo publicLocation signpostStreetView directionsDirections mapMain Map
    Sold Closed May 28, 2019
    $1,200,000
    3 Bedrooms
    3.5 Bathrooms
    2,407 Sqft House
    Built 1999
    2.55 Acres Lot
    2-Car Garage
    5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    SALE HISTORY
    List price was $1,128,000
    It took 5 days to go pending.
    Then 29 days to close at $1,200,000
    Closed at $499/SQFT.
    Custom farmhouse designed by Roger Katz offers beauty and serenity in a park-like setting. An open floor plan features walls of windows, maple and slate floors and stone countertops. Notable details include dormers, crown moldings, a window seat in the master suite and 100 sq ft of covered porched. A 500+ sq ft finished space with bathroom above garage is a perfect art studio or writer's retreat, with ADU potential. Located in the Eagledale on 2.55 private acres with a perimeter of woods.
    Offer Review Date
    This listing's offer review date was Monday, April 29, 2019.
    Listing source NWMLS MLS #
    1441439
    Listed by
    Sarah Sydor, Windermere RE Bainbridge
    Buyer's broker
    Laura R. Rhodes, The Excell Group, Inc.
    Photo 1 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 2 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 3 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 4 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 5 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 6 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 7 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 8 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 9 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 10 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 11 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 12 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 13 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 14 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 15 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 16 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 17 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 18 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 19 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 20 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 21 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 22 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 23 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Photo 24 5864 NE Old Mill Rd Bainbridge Island WA 98110
    Contact our
    Bainbridge Island
    Real Estate Lead
    My Kitsap Homes, LLC
    Phone...
    Email...
    Schedule a Call
    Time Adjusted Estimated Value
    Assumptions: The original sale amount reflected a normal arms length sale. Any major updates would add to the value. Any damage or deferred maintenance would subtract from the value.
    Bedroom & Bathroom Layout
    SECOND
    BDRM
    BDRM
    BDRM
    FULL
    BATH
    FULL
    BATH
    MAIN
    ¾
    BATH
    Property History
    May 14, 2025
    Sold
    $2,198,000
    NWMLS #2352396 Annualized 10.7% / yr
    Apr 17, 2025
    Went Pending
    $2,198,000
    NWMLS #2352396
    Apr 02, 2025
    Listed
    $2,198,000
    NWMLS #2352396
    May 27, 2019
    Sold
    $1,200,000
    NWMLS #1441439
    More
    Listing Details
    • Sale Price
      $1,200,000
    • Closing Date
      May 28, 2019
    • Last List Price
      $1,128,000
    • Original Price
      Same
    • List Date
      April 24, 2019
    • Pending Date
      April 29, 2019
    • Days to go Pending
      5 days
    • $/sqft (Total)
      $499/sqft
    • $/sqft (Finished)
      $499/sqft
    • Listing Source
      NWMLS
    • MLS Number
      1441439
    • Listing Broker
      Sarah Sydor
    • Listing Office
      Windermere RE Bainbridge
    • Buyer's Broker
      Laura R. Rhodes
    • Buyer Broker's Firm
      The Excell Group, Inc.
    Monthly Payment Estimate
    • Principal and Interest
      $6,290 / month
    • Property Taxes
      $736 / month
    • Homeowners Insurance
      $233 / month
    • TOTAL
      $7,259 / month

    • based on 20% down
      ($240,000)
    • and a
      6.85% Interest Rate
    • About:
      All calculations are estimates only and provided by Mainview LLC. Actual amounts will vary.
    House Details
    • Sqft (Total)
      2,407 sqft
    • Sqft (Finished)
      2,407 sqft
    • Sqft (Unfinished)
      None
    • Property Type
      House
    • Sub Type
      2 Story
    • Bedrooms
      3 Bedrooms
    • Bathrooms
      3.5 Bathrooms
    • Lot
      2.55 Acres Lot
    • Lot Size Source
      county records
    • Lot #
      C
    • Project
      Short Plat No. 3059
    • Total Stories
      2 stories
    • Basement
      None
    • Sqft Source
      county records
    Property Tax Info
    • 2019 Property Taxes
      $8,834 / year
    • No Senior Exemption
    Public Parcel Data & Maps
    Schools
    • School District
      Bainbridge Island
    • Elementary
      Capt Johnston Blakel
    • Middle
      Woodward Mid
    • High School
      Bainbridge Isl
    HOA
    • HOA Dues
      Unspecified
    • Fees Assessed
      Unspecified
    • HOA Dues Include
      Unspecified
    • HOA Contact
      Unspecified
    • Management Contact
      Unspecified
    Parking
    • Covered
      2-Car
    • Has Garage
      Yes
    • Nbr of Assigned Spaces
      2
    Views
    • Territorial
    Construction
    • Year Built
      1999
    • Home Builder
      John Paulson
    HVAC
    • Includes
      Forced Air
      Heat Pump
    Cooling
    Heating
    Interior
    • Flooring
      Ceramic Tile
      Hardwood
      Slate
    Property
    • Lot Features
      Secluded
    • Site Features
      Deck
      High Speed Internet
      Patio
      Propane
      RV Parking
    Appliances
    • Included
      Dishwasher
      Dryer
      Microwave
      Range/Oven
      Refrigerator
      Washer
    Terms
    • Bank Owned (REO)
      No
    Utilities
    • Sewer
      Septic Tank
    Additional Info
    • Waterfront
      No
    • Air Conditioning (A/C)
      Yes
    • Buyer Broker's Compensation
      Unspecified
    • MLS Area #
      Area 170
    • Number of Photos
      24
    • Last Modification Time
      Sunday, March 28, 2021 12:28 AM
    • System Listing ID
      1843830
    Update Info
    Listing details based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of Sunday, March 28, 2021 12:28 AM. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
    View
    Sort

    Sharing

     
    Sold May 28, 2019
    $1,200,000   $1,128,000
    3 BR    3.5 BA    2,407 SQFT  
    NWMLS #1441439. Sarah Sydor, Windermere RE Bainbridge
    Map
     
    Listing information is provided by the listing agent except as follows: BuilderB indicates that our system has grouped this listing under a home builder name that doesn't match the name provided by the listing broker. DevelopmentD indicates that our system has grouped this listing under a development name that doesn't match the name provided by the listing broker.
    Neither Wicklund Real Estate nor any officer, agent, or employee of Wicklund Real Estate warrants the accuracy, reliability, or timeliness of any information on this website and shall not be liable for any losses caused by such reliance on the accuracy, reliability, or timeliness of such information. Any person or entity that relies on information obtained from this website does so at his or her own risk. The information contained in each listing has not been verified by Wicklund Real Estate. NWMLS listing data (indicated by the three trees icon) is provided (but not compiled) courtesy of the NWMLS.